Kenilworth Saturday 28/10/17

I'm not an expert of ratings as some of the other guys on here but I think we can say Rose in Bloom, Too Phat to fly and Oh Susanna confirmed the form again and if you use them as the lines, then MW ran to about 94,95 and that would make Snowdance about a 104-105(could have won by further and that's not factored in). Again, I don't really use MR's for the good horses so I'm just guessing here.

mydada wrote: imo MW was given a poor ride ,from draw 7 to get midfield and allowed to have been bunched up onto a short straight was madness

Why is it a poor ride? We all have opinions but why not credit Bernard for a brilliant ride?I do think that Aldo made an error in judgment though,but credit where it's due ?

whatever johnny

market expectation

pirates wrote: Sorry to sound repetitive but i will continue to brass the natal 2yo feature race form when it comes to the cape 3yo season and todays results yet again confirmed my belief as it has done for the past 4 or 5years..

i think your analysis is on the button
i totally agree

MasterOfMyFate wrote: I'm not an expert of ratings as some of the other guys on here but I think we can say Rose in Bloom, Too Phat to fly and Oh Susanna confirmed the form again and if you use them as the lines, then MW ran to about 94,95 and that would make Snowdance about a 104-105(could have won by further and that's not factored in). Again, I don't really use MR's for the good horses so I'm just guessing here.

IMO ...

Tap o' Noth ....... 99
Undercover Agent ..... 97
Cot Campbell ........... 88
Sir Frenchie ............. 91
Sniper Shot ............. 90
Billy Silver ............... 90
Dutch Philip ............ 100

Eyes Wide Open ...... 103


Snowdance ............. 105
Magical Wonderland ... 96
Rose in Bloom .......... 92
Too Phat to Fly ......... 91
Oh Susannah ............ 90


The Tarry filly obviously something amiss or did not handle the left hand turn ... I have her at around 95 on JHB form

I think You are just about spot on ,

Eyes Wide Open ...... 103 - Mydada Maybe this answers your question

i will take it race by race as arguing maths isn't agreeable
tks for the ratings